Scullery vs Butlers Pantry: Which Is Best For Your Home?

Save on your FB feed!

In this post, I’ll explain the difference between a scullery vs butlers pantry.

Both a scullery and a butlers pantry are useful additions to a kitchen. But they have different purposes, and it’s good to know the differences so you can decide which is best for your home.

scullery vs butlers pantry

Are we just going back in time to small closed-off kitchens?

Before open plan living became super popular in the 2010s, most kitchens were closed-off from the rest of the living space.

So is this new scullery trend just going back to what used to be popular??

Not really.

What we’re seeing in the interior design world now is basically re-designing the idea of a walk-in pantry to be larger and more functional.

The open plan kitchen/living trend is still going strong and probably will be for years. But now in larger homes, we’re starting to see the walk-in pantry become more of a secondary ‘dirty kitchen’ – aka the scullery.

What is a scullery?

A scullery is a small space off the kitchen for storing and prepping food, typically with built-in cabinets, counters, a fridge, and appliances like a second stove. It also includes a sink and dishwasher for cleaning up.

When I hear the word “scullery” I imagine old English estates with a British cook working away in the scullery while the household members throw a ball.

And well, that’s kind of what a scullery is used for – food preparation and clean up. Except now you don’t have to own a British estate (though who wouldn’t love that?!).

You can build a new home with a dedicated scullery just off the kitchen and use this space as your secondary kitchen where all the mess happens, keeping the main part of the kitchen clean and tidy.

traditional scullery

A scullery is like a smaller working kitchen complete with cabinets, a sink, fridge and stove.

What is a butlers pantry?

A butler’s pantry is like a deluxe walk-in pantry. It’s a mid-sized walk-in space with cabinets, shelving and countertops where you can store food items and even china and glassware. Some butler’s pantry ideas also include a small sink where you can do light washing up.

butler's pantry

A butler’s pantry has storage options and usually a sink, but lacks cooking appliances found in a scullery.

Scullery vs butlers pantry: what’s the difference?

The biggest difference between a scullery and a butlers pantry is the function of the space.

A scullery is essentially a full working kitchen while a butler’s pantry serves as a storage space.

Both a scullery and a butler’s pantry will be closed-off from the main kitchen area in some way…either tucked around a corner or hidden behind a door.

But a scullery is more of a dirty kitchen area. It’s perfect for people who love to entertain, because all of the pots, pans and other cooking essentials can be hidden away while the main kitchen space is used for serving and gathering.

modern farmhouse scullery

This modern farmhouse scullery has plenty of storage, a sink and a secondary cooking area and is tucked away behind the main kitchen area of the house.

Will a scullery increase the value of your home?

Kitchens with a hidden scullery will almost always increase the value of your home. Prospective buyers would appreciate the option of having extra storage space and a place where they could keep the messier parts of cooking when entertaining guests.

What is the difference between a scullery and a kitchen?

A kitchen is larger than a scullery. In most modern homes now, the kitchen is open to the dining and living rooms of the house so that family and friends can all gather together. A kitchen will have all the usual appliances and is used daily by the family for most meals.

A scullery is a smaller closed-off cooking space near the main kitchen area. It’s essentially a second smaller kitchen that’s meant to hide away the messier parts of cooking and is used primarily during dinner parties.

Walk in pantry with appliance counter

If you’re doing a kitchen renovation and updating your pantry, be sure to plan for appliance storage! A wrap-around counter gives you lots of space to hold appliances so they don’t have to sit out in the open on your kitchen counter.

What is the difference between a walk in pantry and a scullery?

A walk in pantry is what you find in most homes. It’s a small walk-in space with shelves that’s used to store food items. There aren’t any plumbing or appliance hookups in a standard pantry.

A scullery is larger than a normal pantry. It also has cooking appliances and plumbing for a sink and dishwasher.

walk-in pantry

A walk-in pantry only has food storage and lacks the appliances and plumbing that are in a scullery.

Deciding on a scullery vs butlers pantry for your home

Like most home projects, it comes down to what’s best for your lifestyle.

If you just need a space dedicated for storage and minimal prep, a butler’s pantry would suit your needs just fine.

But if you’re wanting more of a small second kitchen area where you (or caterers) could prep for dinner parties and keep all the messy parts of a working kitchen hidden, then a scullery would be your ideal space.


Save on your FB feed!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *